Financial Adviser CompareAdd your business
← Back to Sheffield
ComparePMI

ComparePMI

5.0(14 reviews)See reviews ↓·Sheffield

About the company

ComparePMI is the trading style of ComparePMI Limited, registered in England & Wales. The firm is a small, focused team of private medical insurance specialists with over 35 years of combined experience in financial services. Chris Beecham is CII qualified and has 30 years in financial services, including time at Norwich Union. Ben Metcalfe has 15 years of experience specialising in private medical insurance and holds CAS status. ComparePMI is not authorised or regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and places cover exclusively with FCA-authorised and regulated insurers.

It is registered with the Information Commissioner's Office. ComparePMI never charges clients a fee and may receive commission from an insurer when a policy is placed. It compares 20+ insurers on a whole-of-market basis. ComparePMI specialises only in private medical insurance and health plans for individuals and families. It serves clients across the UK via phone, email or video. ComparePMI provides whole-of-market private medical insurance comparison and advice for individuals, families and businesses.

What customers say

Based on genuine customer reviews

People seeking private medical or life cover describe a straightforward experience with this Sheffield health insurance agency, where the emphasis falls on matching cover to individual circumstances. Several customers highlight the clarity of the options set out, noting that complex policies were explained in plain terms and that different choices were compared before a decision was reached. A recurring theme is the money saved, with reviewers mentioning lower premiums after switching and a good deal found for their needs.

The named adviser, Ben, comes up often for his approachable manner and detailed knowledge across multiple policies, with one client reporting that family protection was arranged within days. Reliability and responsiveness are also praised, and the accuracy of information passed to providers is singled out. Customers refer to the sense of security the arrangements provide and to advice that addressed all their requirements professionally. The service suits both individuals new to insurance and those reviewing existing cover, and the willingness to explain everything over the phone is mentioned repeatedly.

Health insurance agency

Reviews

Reviews are taken from publicly available sources.

RP
Rurai Presho20 February 2026

Great service. Was pretty confused by the whole aspect of life insurance but Ben really helped me. Had protection for my family in place by the end of the week. Would reccomend

SB
Steve Blades19 February 2026

Amazing service from start to finish, Ben was fantastic, can’t recommend enough. Thanks again.

JY
Jason Young30 October 2025

Ben is the perfect man when it comes to insurances. He's given me the best advice with multiple policies and never been wrong. He's approachable, knowledgeable and super reliable. I wouldn't go anywhere else. Thank you Ben

SM
Stella Metford-Sewell29 October 2025

Easy to use helped to save some money

PT
Paul Tierney27 October 2025

The advice given was excellent and all my needs/requirements were addressed in a professional manner, will definitely recommend to friends and family

JP
James Plummer23 October 2025

Ben is very knowledgeable and made the journey of choosing the best option simple and straightforward. Highly recommend.

JG
james greaves23 October 2025

Brilliant site ,helped me get the best deal that suited my needs ,giving me security for the future ,highly recommend !

Insurance brokers in Sheffield compared

Ordered by rating, weighted by the number of reviews — businesses with only a handful of reviews do not jump to the top automatically. 4 businesses in this category in Sheffield are compared.

RankProviderRatingReviewsOpen Sat.
1ComparePMI (this page)★ 5,014Yes
2Clear Insurance Management★ 4,97No
3Everywhen Sheffield★ 4,710No
4Brown & Brown (Previously ECS Insurance Brokers)★ 4,04No
Contact
+441143984301www.comparepmi.co.uk30 Tylney Rd, Sheffield S2 2RY
Working hours
Monday09:00–17:00
Tuesday09:00–17:00
Wednesday09:00–17:00
Thursday09:00–17:00
Friday09:00–17:00
Saturday09:00–17:00
SundayClosed